CONTACT INFORMATION :

About Me:
Real Name: Duncan Black
Age: 34
Location: Philadelphia

RSS Feed
Latest
Archives
Amazon Wish List


Support this Site:



Search Now:  
Amazon Logo

Philly Bloggers
Rittenhouse Review
corrente
Suburban Guerilla
Upyernoz
Philly Future
All Spin Zone
Young Philly Politics
Booman Tribune
She Flies...
Phillyist
Metroblog
Philly
MyDD
Mithras
Slacktivist
Will Bunch
Blogs

Pandagon
Daily Kos
TBogg
First Draft
Cursor
Talk Left
Matthew Yglesias
Roger Ailes
Sadly, No!
TAPPED
Max Speak
Altercation
Josh Marshall
Hullabaloo
Orcinus
Kicking Ass
Brad DeLong
Wolcott
Bob Harris
Daou Report
SirotaBlog
Steve Gilliard
From the Roots
ConWebWatch
Daily Howler
Liquid List
Crooks&Liars
Washington Monthly
Dependable Renegade
Left Coaster
Unqualified Offerings
Fanatical Apathy Tom Tomorrow
WampumBlog
Majikthise
ATTAEFFINGTURK
Beautiful Horizons
The Sideshow
Road to Surfdom
AmericaBlog
Feministing
Think Progress
Adventus
Stakeholder
Echidne
Stinging Nettle
Firedoglake
Feministe
War Liberal
War and Piece
Oliver Willis
Ezra Klein
LG&M
No More MNB
Throwing Things
Unclaimed Territory
DownWithTyranny
Talent Show
Angry Bear
Hoffmania
RoxPopuli
Am I Patriotic?
Making Light
Mikhaela
Xoverboard
Liberal Oasis
Berube
Froomkin
Other Froomkin
Today in Iraq
Peking Duck
Democratic Veteran
Jack Balkin
alicublog
Skimble
Mahablog
Demagogue
Margaret Cho
ArchPundit
FaBlog
Alas, a Blog
Talking Dog
General J.C. Christian
Dohiyimir
Needle Nose
Crooked Timber
GOTV
The American Street
World O'Crap
Looking Glass
Julian Sanchez
Gene Healy
Fafblog
Whiskey Fire
Brian Flemming
BusyBusyBusy
Annatopia
KnoxViews
A Brooklyn Bridge
Pacific Views
The Big Picture
Shakespeare's Sister
Bitch, Ph.D
Mad Kane
AgendaBender
Naked Writing
Ed Cone
Deride and Conquer
Off the Kuff
Public Nuisance
UggaBugga
Nathan Newman
Demosthenes
WTF is it Now?
Blah3
Poor Man
Seeing the Forest
Bad Attitudes
Sisyphus Shrugged

Lean Left
Light of Reason
skippy
Doxagora
Martin Wisse
Scoobie Davis




 
 
check to have links open new windows


Thursday, December 21, 2006
 
Journamalism

One thing I've tried very hard to do on this blog is never presume to speak for the soldiers who are serving in Iraq. An obvious reason for this is that they of course don't speak with one voice or one mind. Still, how credulous can a reporter be who writes this up without pointing out the obvious:

FRONT-LINE TROOPS WANT REINFORCEMENTS

Gates had breakfast with U.S. soldiers to hear their views.

"Sir, I think we need to just keep doing what we're doing," Specialist Jason Glenn told Gates.

"I really think we need more troops here. With more presence on the ground, more troops might hold them (the insurgents) off long enough to where we can get the Iraqi army trained up."

None of the soldiers present said U.S. forces should be brought home, and none said current troop levels were adequate.

A senior defense official in Baghdad said U.S. commanders were concerned a surge in the number of troops would make the Iraqis feel less under pressure to take full responsibility for security.

"Look, the Iraqis are smart. They see what we do, and if we surge, they can step back," the official said.

Gates said it was not surprising troops wanted reinforcements. "We have to take into account the views of the Iraqi government the views of our own leadership, the views of our own military leadership in taking that into account."


I wouldn't be surprised if plenty of the people on the front lines felt this way. Hell, maybe most of them. How would I know? But implicit in this news report is the idea that this hand-picked small group of soldiers was somehow just some random representative group of soldiers instead of, you know, a hand-picked group chosen for there... oh, I don't know, maybe for their views on the situation in Iraq.

I'm not impugning the integrity of these people. They may believe these things sincerely. That isn't the issue. The issue is pretending that when the new Secretary of Defense shows up to talk "to the troops" that those people chosen for that talk are a representative random group.



Disclaimer:
This is a personal web site. It is not a production of Media Matters for America (MMFA). Statements on this site do not represent the views or policies of MMFA. Preferences for electoral candidates posted on this site have not been expressed using any MMFA resources.


 

 
 




Drinking Liberally
In Philadelphia, Tuesdays at Tangier, 18th and Lombard 6-9pm
Check for a location in your town.